Discussion:
Zinc reeds on aluminium reed plate?
(too old to reply)
f***@gmail.com
2020-05-04 15:02:19 UTC
Permalink
Has anyone ever seen an instance of reed plates made of aluminium but the reeds themselves being made of zinc?

I own a 1940's German accordion that seems to have this.
Ike Milligan
2020-05-05 11:53:59 UTC
Permalink
Post by f***@gmail.com
Has anyone ever seen an instance of reed plates made of aluminium but the reeds themselves being made of zinc?
I own a 1940's German accordion that seems to have this.
No. it has zinc plates? R U nuts?
f***@gmail.com
2020-05-05 14:12:20 UTC
Permalink
No it has aluminum plates but the reeds are much darker metal. Are you blind?
Ike Milligan
2020-05-05 18:02:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by f***@gmail.com
No it has aluminum plates but the reeds are much darker metal. Are you blind?
I would much like to solve your question but this site has no pictures.
you would need to post a link to a picture of the reeds or send a
picture to my email address.
Ike Milligan
2020-05-07 14:30:35 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ike Milligan
Post by f***@gmail.com
No it has aluminum plates but the reeds are much darker metal. Are you blind?
I would much like to solve your question but this site has no pictures.
you would need to post a link to a picture of the reeds or send a
picture to my email address.
You're clueless...

A black hole marks the spot where your deity divided by zero.

This idiot talks about a black hole dividing by zero as though he were
an intelligent theiretical phycicist versed in mathematics.
This is what happens when you hit "reply" instead of "followup"... Any
idiot can call you clueless without witnesses.

Ciueless about what? Reeds have to be made of a flexible metal. no one
would make them out of zinc. They would not even vibrate. A picture was
mentioned but not available. Stop wasting time.
Post by Ike Milligan
No one has ever seen it, and neither have you.
Maybe your nomenclature is wrong. Steel can turn black if a
chemical is
Post by Ike Milligan
used to remove rust. Naval jelly or other chemicals containing
phosphoric acid Will ruin the reeds. The only way to remove rust without
ruining the reeds is by hand mechanically without any abrading of the
plates. Acid of any kind would ruin the reed plates. The steel reeds
would also be totally ruined by the chemical.
In the 1940s German reed plates were zinc to save aluminum.
An acid
Post by Ike Milligan
might have removed the gray oxide from the zinc and turned it silver.
The entire set of reeds on zinc plates is difficult or impossible to
adequately restore because zinc is unstable and will oxidize over time.
The white powdery oxide degrades the reed plate and even when it is
removed, it seems to come back and the reed will sound bad.
The accordion is ruined. Sorry. It was probably not
salvageable in the
Post by Ike Milligan
beginning if it was water damaged.
Thanks for posting. If you have something to look at post the
picture
Post by Ike Milligan
elsewhere with a URL.
Ike Milligan
2020-05-07 14:34:31 UTC
Permalink
Post by Ike Milligan
Post by Ike Milligan
Post by f***@gmail.com
No it has aluminum plates but the reeds are much darker metal. Are you blind?
I would much like to solve your question but this site has no
pictures. you would need to post a link to a picture of the reeds or
send a picture to my email address.
You're clueless...
A black hole marks the spot where your deity divided by zero.
This idiot talks about a black hole dividing by zero as though he were
an intelligent theiretical phycicist versed in mathematics.
This is what happens when you hit "reply" instead of "followup"... Any
idiot can call you clueless without witnesses.
Ciueless about what? Reeds have to be made of a flexible metal. no one
would make them out of zinc. They would not even vibrate. A picture was
mentioned but not available. Stop wasting time.
Post by Ike Milligan
No one has ever seen it, and neither have you.
         Maybe your nomenclature is wrong. Steel can turn black if a
chemical is
Post by Ike Milligan
used to remove rust. Naval jelly or other chemicals containing
phosphoric acid Will ruin the reeds. The only way to remove rust without
ruining the reeds is by hand mechanically without any abrading of the
plates. Acid of any kind would ruin the reed plates. The steel reeds
would also be totally ruined by the chemical.
         In the 1940s German reed plates were zinc to save aluminum.
An acid
Post by Ike Milligan
might have removed the gray oxide from the zinc and turned it silver.
The entire set of reeds on zinc plates is difficult or impossible to
adequately restore because zinc is unstable and will oxidize over time.
The white powdery oxide degrades the reed plate and even when it is
removed, it seems to come back and the reed will sound bad.
         The accordion is ruined. Sorry. It was probably not
salvageable in the
Post by Ike Milligan
beginning if it was water damaged.
         Thanks for posting. If you have something to look at post the
picture
Post by Ike Milligan
elsewhere with a URL.
WHen brains were being passed out to fetuses your zygote thought the
Maker said "Rain" instead of "brain" anad hid under a tree.

Loading...